Thursday 29 May 2014

Did imperialism ultimately leave a more positive impact on the world as we know it today?

This question is of course a matter of opinion, and the answer may well depend on one's perspective. Certainly, some who would argue that imperialism had significant positive results might point to several results, including the eradication of some diseases by Western initiatives, the introduction of some Western ideas and technologies, and perhaps even that some colonial peoples, usually favored elites, flourished and became quite wealthy under European rule. 


But ultimately, I would argue that...

This question is of course a matter of opinion, and the answer may well depend on one's perspective. Certainly, some who would argue that imperialism had significant positive results might point to several results, including the eradication of some diseases by Western initiatives, the introduction of some Western ideas and technologies, and perhaps even that some colonial peoples, usually favored elites, flourished and became quite wealthy under European rule. 


But ultimately, I would argue that the effects of imperialism were hardly a net positive for former colonies. Many colonies were gained and maintained through warfare and violence as indigenous peoples resisted European rule. European imperialists tended to create divisions where none had previously existed by favoring one group over another for positions in local government and other privileges. This created animosities that persisted well into the post-colonial period, sometimes with disastrous consequences (like the Rwandan genocide). 


Imperialism also typically involved the expropriation of wealth, usually in the form of natural resources, from people around the world. Lands were put to growing cash crops, forests were cleared, mines were worked, all for the profit of the imperialist power (or often private businesses granted rights within the colonies). This arrangement also persists into modern times in many countries around the world. Imperialism also tended to involve attempts to impose Western culture on peoples around the world, to the detriment of native culture. Finally, imperialist powers often redrew the maps of Asia and Africa in ways that did not really reflect the ethnic realities on the ground. So people with longstanding grievances with each other were crammed within artificially-imposed borders even when colonies gained independence. Throughout Africa and the Middle East, this has led to violence and civil war. So overall, I would suggest (along with the majority of academic historians) that whatever positive outcomes may have resulted from imperialism, it ultimately had a negative effect on the peoples caught up in it.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Is there any personification in "The Tell-Tale Heart"?

Personification is a literary device in which the author attributes human characteristics and features to inanimate objects, ideas, or anima...